People often have very strong ideas about discipline when raising kids, and it’s easy to go to either extreme. You might be told kids need to be told what to do all the time, to do it right away, or to face really serious punishments to be respectful. However, the people who study how children grow and change usually have a more sensible outlook. Disciplining well isn’t so much about being in charge, but about showing children how they should act and helping them learn to do that over time.
The American Academy of Pediatrics says that discipline that works actually helps kids develop healthily and lowers aggression, and arguments within the family. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention also suggests ways of being a parent that are positive, using boundaries, encouragement, and responding the same way each time. These viewpoints go against many common (and not very useful) beliefs about discipline, beliefs that unfortunately still affect how a lot of families live.
Myth 1: Good Discipline Means Immediate Obedience Every Time
When we have certain ideas about how children should be, typical steps in growing up can seem like something is going wrong. Little kids are still developing the ability to stop themselves doing something, manage their feelings, and deal with being annoyed. So, a child not doing as you ask isn’t necessarily being deliberately difficult. It’s possible it’s because of how far they’ve progressed in their development, if they’re stressed, if they’re tired, or if they find it hard to move from one activity to another.
Most professionals who work with children don’t prioritize immediate obedience. Instead they are more interested in whether a child is gradually learning what’s expected of them. Repeating yourself, being consistent in your approach, and gently pointing out what to do are often far more effective than seeing every time they are slow to respond as a battle of wills.
Myth 2: Discipline Works Best When Adults React Strongly
Lots of families think that being really emotional will make their discipline work better, but professionals generally don’t see it that way. If an adult gets very upset, kids are much more likely to pay attention to how angry the adult is and not to what they are being told. And that can make things worse, with kids being more afraid, things getting out of hand or turning into a fight for control, instead of actually improving their behaviour.
The American Academy of Pediatrics’ advice on discipline is usually to be calm and respond in the same way each time. Kids understand and learn from things much better when they know exactly what’s expected and when those expectations won’t change. Serious misbehaviour isn’t overlooked by this at all, it just means dealing with it in a way that is instructive, rather than making the situation even more heated.
Credit: Pexels
Myth 3: Praise Spoils Children
A lot of adults think complimenting kids too much will make it harder to get them to behave, but people who know about raising children generally have a different view of empty compliments and being specifically told what was good about what they did. In fact, the CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) says when you’re talking to your kids about their behaviour, you should be sure to actually see the good things and say what they are. This way children learn what they did that was good and are more likely to do it again.
Saying something like “You put your shoes away immediately when I asked” is a lot more helpful than simply saying “good job”. This type of specific praise actually helps with discipline as it makes certain behaviours the family is trying to encourage, stronger.
Myth 4: The Same Discipline Method Works for Every Child
Kids are all different – in how old they are, what their personalities are like, how well they use words, how easily they’re bothered by things, and where they are in growing up. What gets one child to do something won’t necessarily work for their brother or sister. Most people who understand children suggest families should have the same core beliefs and what they want from their kids, but change the way they explain things and react depending on each child’s specific needs.
Doing this isn’t treating anyone unfairly. It’s simply understanding that kids all take being told when they’re wrong in their own way. And, families get along better with arguments when they get away from the idea that a single solution will be exactly the same for all of their children.
Myth 5: Discipline Is Only About Stopping Bad Behavior
A really common and unhelpful belief is that discipline is just for stopping children from doing wrong. However, people who really know about raising kids say discipline is also about showing children new ways to do things – things like asking for assistance, being patient for your time, being polite in how you talk, or getting control of yourself before you do something. If you don’t include this part of teaching them, a telling-off might halt the bad behaviour for a moment but won’t give them a good choice to do instead.
The American Academy of Pediatrics’ wider advice for parents shows this focus on teaching. Kids require adults to explain, demonstrate, go over again, and emphasize how good behaviour looks in everyday life. Because of this, discipline is most effective as a continuing method, not a bunch of separate punishments.
Credit: Pexels
Why Better Discipline Usually Looks Less Dramatic
Discipline that really works is usually pretty calm, not as loud as many families imagine. It’s built around things like everyday schedules, being very specific with what you’re praising, saying the same boundaries over and over, and correcting behavior in a solid way, though without getting overly upset. This isn’t as showy as just reacting to things, but people who know about kids (and how they grow) usually think it actually works better in the long run.
Arguments in families get trickier to handle if punishments are based on what people think should happen, and not on how children actually develop. Lots of normal daily battles become much easier to deal with when adults move away from simply trying to be in charge and start to respond to things as if they are teaching opportunities.
Key Takeaway
When we believe untrue things about discipline, arguments in the family can get worse as both kids and grown-ups start to expect too much of each other. Specialists at this point usually suggest being steady and relaxed when you’re teaching, being very clear when you say what a child did well, and expecting things of them that fit their age. Instead of getting really angry, that’s what they advise. Discipline is at its best if it shows children how they should behave, as opposed to just what they shouldn’t. With time, doing things this way will likely lower the number of disagreements and improve how everyone in the family talks to each other.